Convinced it's an "Indian issue", neighboring sheriffs are reluctant to get involved. Tempers flare—and Kate knows things are bound to get even more heated. But when Kate and Kyle start to gather evidence, they realize the case isn't at all what it seems. Their search for Shelly has uncovered deep-buried family secrets, and soon, Shelly isn't the only one in danger. As Kate struggles to nail down a suspect—and with the truth seeming just out of reach—the new sheriff knows she's running out of time. And then she makes a big mistake. Can Kate right the wrong in time to save the life that's hanging in the balance?